Connect with us

Software

MUSCLE v/s T-COFFEE : An overview and different aspects

Published

on

As I have discussed in my earlier articles about the multiple sequence alignment (MSA) tools (MUSCLE & T-COFFEE). Now in this article, we will discuss different aspects of these tools and which one is more preferred over the another. MUSCLE and T-COFFEE both are multiple sequence alignment tools and also helps to study the evolutionary relationships among the species.As I have already explained the algorithms involved in both the tools which are comparable. During the alignment using MUSCLE, it uses the UPGMA tree construction method which assumes that mutation occurs at the constant rate. This may be a fact which makes it different from other tools.

On the positive side, MUSCLE is a tool which is known for its speed and accuracy on each of the four benchmark test sets ( BAliBASE, SABmark, SMART and PREFAB). It is much faster than other MSA tools. MUSCLE also uses a progressive alignment which is iterated while it gets a better SP score (explained in “Basic concept of MSA” article).

T-COFFEE is an improvisation over MUSCLE in the sense that it combines both global and local alignments which provides better results and it also qualifies the four benchmark tests. Second thing which makes it better than other tools is that it uses an optimization method which provides the multiple alignment that best fits in the input library. T-COFFEE also uses progressive alignment strategy similar to MUSCLE, but unlike MUSCLE, T-COFFEE uses Neighbor Joining tree construction method during alignment which corrects the assumption of UPGMA method and assumes that mutation never occurs at a constant rate.

Let us take protein sequences of ‘Keratin’ protein of few species and align them using both the tools and construct the respective phylogeny trees. In this example, I have taken FASTA sequences of: Homo sapiens (GI: 7717238) , Paralichthys olivaceus (GI: 10716084), Pseudomonas viridiflava (GI: 934022154) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (GI: 856785229). The results are as follows:

Fig.1
Fig 1. Tree constructed using MUSCLE.
Fig.2
Fig 2. Tree constructed using T-COFFEE.

As we have seen both the trees are slight different. The sequence of Paralichthys olivaceus is placed below to that of Homo sapiens, but it is placed above in tree constructed by T-COFFEE. Similarly, this is case with other two species. This is how MUSCLE & T-COFFEE are different from each other. T-COFFEE is more preferred over MUSCLE while aligning both closely or distantly related species but MUSCLE ia more suitable to align distantly related species since it uses global alignment only, but T-COFFEE uses both.

Note:

An exhaustive list of references for this article is available with the author and is available on personal request, for more details write to [email protected]

Dr. Muniba is a Bioinformatician based in New Delhi, India. She has completed her PhD in Bioinformatics from South China University of Technology, Guangzhou, China. She has cutting edge knowledge of bioinformatics tools, algorithms, and drug designing. When she is not reading she is found enjoying with the family. Know more about Muniba

Advertisement
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Software

How to calculate binding pocket volume using PyVol plugin in PyMol?

Published

on

How to calculate binding pocket volume using PyVol plugin in PyMol?

Previously, we provided a tutorial for PyVol plugin [1] installation. In this article, we will calculate the binding pocket volume of protein using the same plugin in PyMol [2]. (more…)

Continue Reading

Software

How to generate electron density map using Pymol?

Published

on

How to generate electron density map using Pymol?

Electron density maps are available for most of the protein structures in PDB. Therefore, in this article, we are using PDB to generate electron density maps in Pymol.

(more…)

Continue Reading

Software

Installing PyVOL plugin in Pymol on Ubuntu (Linux).

Published

on

Installing PyVOL plugin in Pymol on Ubuntu (Linux).

PyVOL [1] is an excellent plugin of Pymol [2] for pocket visualization of proteins. In this article, we will install the PyVOL plugin in Pymol on Ubuntu. (more…)

Continue Reading

LATEST ISSUE

ADVERT